The Price of KingsMenu

Production diary · 2012 · Richard Symons

Peres making the Grade

Illustrated film frame: a colonnaded assembly hall
Archive illustration for this diary entry

Much talk in the office of President Peres (and his Facebook initiative) as we hit the final stretch of preparing the Shimon Peres film for release in April (just completed the sound and about to finish off grading the colour).

There's a substantial difference between this and the first film in the series on Yasser Arafat - mainly because President Peres is still with us and we interviewed the man himself over a couple of days.

That said, similarities in the challenges of leadership faced by these two Presidents on opposite sides of the Middle East conflict are remarkable, especially when you consider how the leaders dealt with extremists on both the Palestinian and Israeli side. The real differences come when you compare current news from the conflict to the 1993 Oslo Peace negotiations when Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin alongside Shimon Peres and Yasser Arafat were determined to bring peace. In those days, Yitzhak Rabin and Shimon Peres stood up to the Israeli right wing (in particular the settlers) and that's the main source of debate in the office... Why doesn't current Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu do the same? Should President Peres be more vocal in standing up to Netanyahu and the settlements in public? There's a difference between Peres advocating peace whenever he can and Peres criticising the current government. That difference cuts right to the question at the heart of The Price of Kings, "What would you sacrifice for what you believe?"

President Peres now has a much more constitutional role and is technically limited as to what he can do politically. But will he risk breaching his constitutional role for the sake of what he believes? In the film, the 5th President of Israel, Yitzhak Navon clearly saw his own presidential role as having a moral core which over-rode any political considerations - that's how he justified insisting on an enquiry into the massacres of Palestinian refugees in 1982 whilst they were being guarded by the Israeli Defence Force at the Sabra and Shatilla refugees camps in Lebanon. Critics of President Peres note his silence (at least in public) on recent concerns - like how the IDF conducted operation Cast Lead in Gaza - and they're asking why?

There's no doubt that Shimon Peres has been an exceptional nation-builder and enjoyed a phenomenal political career (unmatched in longevity by any other political leader in the world), but how does his current activity compare to 1993 when alongside Rabin he came so achingly close to bringing about a meaningful peace in the Middle East.

Shimon Peres called a couple of weeks ago after seeing the final cut of his film and told us he preferred his earlier, more controversial years in a way that suggested he now accepted the restrictions of being President. It made me think of something I hadn't previously associated with him and perhaps this is a factor of his age. All leaders face circumstances where they face a choice between the lesser of two evils, requiring a tough decision. But there's always another option - no matter how restrained/limited/constrained the circumstances there's always a third way.

During filming, pretty much everyone we interviewed felt so seated in their role as a leader that I constantly had to remind myself of this blatantly obvious third course of action - resignation. Don't make the choice. Opt out. Who needs the aggravation of leadership? Much of President Peres's brilliance as a leader, ability as a nation builder came from his simple refusal to give up - from buying arms for the 1948 War of Independence to the Raid on Entebbe, The Oslo Peace deal, Israel's nuclear programme... all of these were the result of Peres refusing to resign when confronted by tough decisions, unanimous opposition and certainly flying in the face of traditional thought. Perhaps it's because he's been so successful in the past at going against the grain that so many of Israel's left wing, men like Uri Avnery and Gideon Levy, think the last thing that should be constraining President Peres now is the acceptance of the limitations in his constitutional role as President of Israel? Which brings us to the question that's been plaguing our office - will he sacrifice the role of President for what he believes or is the belief not strong enough for him to make the sacrifice.

Read more about The Price of Kings: Shimon Peres

Preserved from the series production diary, first published 2012. Time references (“this week”, “next month”) are those of the original post.

Related reading

Diary · 2012

Shimon Peres v. Albert Einstein

As we get ready to release The Price of Kings: Film 2 - Shimon Peres in April, wherever we turn the figure at the heart of the middle east conflict seems to be making…

Diary · 2012

Israeli Settlers Eviction in Hebron

In Hebron, the settlers’ claim of a biblical right to the land is inextricably bound up in (and some would say underpins) the conflict between Zionism and the much…