Production diary · 2012 · Emma Norton
Leadership and Morality

Earlier this week Archbishop Desmond Tutu announced that he was stepping down from speaking at a forthcoming leadership summit in Johannesburg because British ex-Prime Minister Tony Blair was scheduled to speak at the same conference.
Tutu has long expressed his distaste for Blair’s decision to go to war in Iraq, but this latest public statement of disapproval has come with rather surprising reasoning.
The Archbishop's office stated that: "The Discovery Invest Summit has leadership as its theme. Morality and leadership are indivisible. In this context, it would be inappropriate for the Archbishop to share a platform with Mr Blair."
Tutu’s interpretation of leadership as being intrinsically tied to morality is unusual; especially considering the broad nature of the statement his office made. Tutu’s announcement made no distinction between elected leaders such as Blair, and spiritual or cultural leaders such as Desmond Tutu himself, Gandhi or Martin Luther King.
Most would argue that whilst our spiritual and cultural leaders set out their stall to moral leadership, it is not explicitly within our elected representatives’ job description to be ‘moral’. The qualities ascribed to elected leaders are more likely to be related to intelligence, accountability, pragmatism, and increasingly, charisma. This is not to say that our elected leaders should make immoral decisions, or that their own moral beliefs should not factor, to some extent, in the decisions they make.
Indeed, in making our films on leadership, the issue of moral leadership did arise on several occasions; our contributors told us about instances when they did make moral considerations when making important decisions.
Subject of our second film, Shimon Peres, told us that ‘morality’ did factor into his decision making: “what I want to make sure there is a moral consideration, even in war. Never forget the moral supremacy in all your judgment.’
But, with the complexities of the situation in Israel and Palestine, morality can become skewed and, as Peres said, “There is one thing that I remember too; since we're at war, the discrimination has another reason, the suspicion that say, an Arab, may kill you. That complicates the clear cut distinction.”
The subject of our third film, Oscar Arias, however, seems to share similar attitudes to Archbishop Tutu when it comes to the issue of moral leadership.
He told us; “It is always important to fight for what you think is right, to defend with good arguments, your convictions, your ideas, not to bend too much on your principles because then they break.”
Arias consistently did what he thought was right for his country, even when his choices were not popular. In his first term, Arias fought for peace with Costa Rica’s neighbouring countries, even though “peace was not popular”. In his second term, Arias fought for the economic interests of his country, pushing though the highly divisive and unpopular Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA), and allowing open pit mining in the northern countryside despite the Costa Rican public’s deep commitment to Environmental protection.
Yet Oscar Arias is a highly unusual leader and politician, his close ally Kevin Casas highlighted Arias’ remarkable naivety when he told us;
“I remember vividly one episode when I was working at the Arias foundation… it was around the time that Bill Clinton was trying to get his welfare reform through and all of a sudden [Arias] started thinking aloud… ‘well I really don't understand how these Democrats that I met are voting in favour of this welfare reform that they don't believe in. Voting in something you don't believe in, that's something I really, really don't understand.’… For me, that moment was a watershed and I came to realise that behind the public persona and behind his ability to stand up for his convictions, there was definitely something very genuine and very deep.”
In the end, Arias’ commitment to his ideals destroyed him politically. He left office with the lowest approval rating of his career; the success of his first term in office and his work to achieve peace was forgotten. President Arias became a hated and ridiculed figure.
Learn more about the political life of Oscar Arias on the page for 'The Price of Kings - Film 3: Oscar Arias'.
Preserved from the series production diary, first published 2012. Time references (“this week”, “next month”) are those of the original post.


